Paul, April 19, 2011
Here we are with the last of the Pain au Levain triumvirate, the Whole Wheat variation, all of course from Jeffrey Hamelman’s great book Bread: A Baker’s Book of Techniques and Recipes.
With respect to full disclosure, note that this bread is made with white bread flour, whole wheat flour and a little rye, so it’s not really and truly “whole wheat”, should some of you be reluctant to try a bread that’s too “grainy”. In fact, there’s not a whole lot of whole wheat in it but enough to give it a distinct taste.
And for those who are reluctant to eat sourdough bread because you think it’s “too sour”, breathe easy: this one isn’t sour at all.
If you’ve followed along, the earlier Pain au Levain and Pain au Levain with Mixed Starters followed basically the same process: start the starter(s) 12 – 16 hours before so this is the same case today. This time, it was a somewhat stiff starter at 60% hydration.
So let’s get this bread going!
We start with the usual Mis en Place and get ourselves organized.
As noted: bread flour, whole wheat and a little rye flour, stiff starter, water and salt.
The three flours and water are first mixed; note that I’ve held back about 50Ml of the water as I’d found that the flour had absorbed a fair bit of humidity and had come out rather wet before. The salt and stiff starter are also held back.
Once the flour was mixed to a shaggy texture, it is left to autolyse for 20 – 60 minutes; I went 60 this time around since I started the bread quite early in the morning and had time to spare.
After the autolyse, the starter and salt are added to the dough and kneaded with the dough hook until smooth and a good windowpane test can be pulled. A little difficult with whole wheat as the bits of grain tend to cut the gluten strands. But I still got a fairly even translucent and solid pane so we were good to go,
While kneading, I found the dough was a tad dry after all so I added about 2 teaspoons of water which got the dough to display the “kneading foot” where it stuck just at the bottom of the bowl.
With the kneading finished, the dough is placed into the plastic oiled bowl and bulk proofed with two Stretch and Folds at 50 minute intervals. Total bulk proofing time: 2.5 hours.
Once done, the dough is weighed and divided into three portions of 495 grams.
The three parts are then shaped into regular loaves this time.
Once formed, the dough is placed in the couche and allowed to do the final proof for 2 – 2.5 hours. I checked them at 2 hours, gave the poke test and decided to let them go the full 2.5 hours.
At that point, the dough is transferred to the lined baking pan and slashed. While doing this I tossed a cup of hot water into the 440ºF oven to build up the steam. Unfortunately, I did get a little too rushed here and didn’t slash the loaves quite deep enough. Into the oven they went anyway, along with another cup of water.
Fourty minutes later, the loaves came out of the oven, a nice deep golden colour (a bit darker than they seem in this photo) and allowed to cool for 30-40 minutes.
Here’s the official Glam shot:
… and later, I got the Crumb shot too.
The verdict? Very nice again! Although the too timid slashing caused the bread to not expand as much as it likely could have (and get a bit of bursting on the bottom which you can sort of see in the slice above), this bread came out pretty nice. Better slashing need more determined action!! Must remember this.
Flavour of this one is a little more nutty than the previous Mixed Starter version. The crust came out somewhat thin but still with a little chew and a good taste. No overly done bottom this time – placing the laoves on double pans has helped eliminate the too-hot bottom issue. The sourdough brings along a nice flavour without making the bread ‘sour’; the slight sweetness of the whole wheat and rye still add a subtle tone.
So which of the three varieties wins? Frankly, none and all of them. Although they have decidedly notable flavour differences, I can’t say one was “better” then the next. Different, a bit, yes. But they were all very good. Since they basically all followed the same process, that part of it didn’t make any of them easier or harder to make. The Mixed Starter did need two starters made up but that might have taken two more minutes to mix the rye up, hardly a deal breaker.
This set of breads has proven to be very enjoyable and the fact I’ve been able to knock out a few issues with the stove and ‘humid” flour was rewarding. These would decidedly go into the “make Again” pile.
Check out other Mellow Bakers making these pains au Levain here!
This bread was submitted to YeastSpotting on the WildYeastBlog.com